United States Presidential election7 Nov 2028in 717 days Senate D 99% House D 58% Calendar Track record Research

Kansas, which Trump won by 16 points, is a Senate toss-up

Adam Hamilton leads Roger Marshall by a point in our poll average, but the state's lean and its polling record keep Marshall a narrow favorite.

Written in house from our poll data and our forecast.

Kansas State Capitol in summer 2024.jpg
Photo: Nils Huenerfuerst, CC BY 4.0

Adam Hamilton, a pastor from the Kansas City suburbs, leads Senator Roger Marshall by 1.2 points in our average of Kansas polls. Our forecast still makes Marshall a narrow favorite, winning 53% of our 5,000 simulations to Hamilton's 47%, because a state that voted for Donald Trump by 16 points in 2024 does not give up a Senate seat easily. Kansas has not elected a Democrat to the Senate since 1932. It is now one of three toss-ups and, after Iowa, the race that most often decides control of the chamber in our simulations.

The polls

Twelve general-election polls of Hamilton against Marshall are in our average. Hamilton leads in seven, Marshall in three, and two are tied. The newest, from InsiderAdvantage and finished on 10 October, had Hamilton ahead 48 to 47. YouGov had him up three and GBAO up five, both on 4 October. Trafalgar Group and Siena College each found a tie at the start of the month. Emerson College, Global Strategy Group and Wedgewood Polls, all in the second half of September, had Hamilton ahead by about two.

Two things in that list stand out. The polls paid for by Democrats over the summer, by GBAO, Public Policy Polling and Global Strategy Group, were among the best for Marshall: two had him ahead and the third had Hamilton up by about a point. And the only poll with Marshall clearly ahead since then, co/efficient's on 10 September with him up 5.3 on the decided vote, was sponsored by a Republican client. Our average adjusts each poll for its pollster's house effect at past final polls and takes off the 2.5 points by which campaign and party polls have leaned to their own side, so Siena's tie becomes R+1.7 and co/efficient's lead R+1.7. We now also count InsiderAdvantage's and Trafalgar Group's polls as Republican-sponsored, so their figures move the other way: InsiderAdvantage's one-point lead for Hamilton becomes D+4.3 and Trafalgar's tie D+4.7, and each carries half the usual weight. Of the nine polls taken since the start of September, none is more than 4.7 points from even after adjustment.

Fundamentals against the polls

The polls say toss-up; the state's history says otherwise. Our fundamentals start from Kansas's presidential lean, R+15.8 against the nation, add the national House vote, which we read at D+6.7, and give Marshall 9.6 points for incumbency. On those alone, Marshall would win by 15 points.

The forecast blends the two in inverse proportion to their measured errors. With 12 polls the race average is much the more reliable guide, so it carries 90% of the weight and the fundamentals the rest. That small share is enough to turn a D+1.2 poll average into a projection of Marshall by 0.5 points. In 80% of our simulations the result falls between R+7.8 and D+6.9.

How it moved

Kansas has been the slowest-built battleground of the year. Rebuilt from the polls published at each date, our forecast gave the Democrat 23% on 1 January, when there were no polls of the race and the fundamentals put Marshall ahead by almost 19 points. Early polls showed Marshall ahead, and Hamilton's chance fell to its low of 11% in the first week of August.

It turned in September. When an August poll by Global Strategy Group for a Democratic group joined the average on 12 September, the average moved from R+4.5 to R+2.8, we moved the race from Likely R to Leans R, and the chance reached 22%. By 18 September, with co/efficient's poll added, the average had crossed to D+0.7 and Hamilton's chance stood at 38%. It reached 41% once Emerson's poll was in. We rated the race a toss-up on 6 October. It peaked at 48% on 10 October and stands at 47% after a small move toward the Republicans in our national reading, which also lowered the Democrats' chances in Iowa, Texas and South Carolina.

Kansas's polling record

A one-point lead in Kansas polls is not much to bank on. We hold final polls for ten Kansas Senate and governor races since 2002. On average they came within 3.0 points of the margin, with no consistent lean to either party: the average miss was 0.2 points toward the Democrats.

The competitive races are another matter. In the 2014 governor's race, nine final polls had the Democrat Paul Davis ahead by 3.1 points; Sam Brownback won by 3.7. In 2018, four final polls had Laura Kelly up by 0.8 points; she won the governorship by 5.1. And in 2020, six final polls had Marshall himself ahead of Barbara Bollier by 4.4 points. He won by 11.4, a miss of 7.0 points in the Republicans' direction. In 2022, by contrast, the two final polls of Kelly's re-election matched her 2.2-point win exactly.

Our race page replays each past cycle's national error in Senate and governor polls on this race. Three of the 12 cycles, 2006, 2010 and 2012, would hand the seat to Hamilton; in the other nine Marshall holds it, by up to 7.4 points in a 2020-sized miss.

The campaign

Hamilton founded the Church of the Resurrection in Leawood and first explored an independent run before winning the Democratic primary on 4 August with about 35% of the vote, according to Wikipedia's record of the results. He has been endorsed by the former Republican governor Bill Graves and the former Democratic governor Kathleen Sebelius. Marshall, an obstetrician first elected in 2020, won his primary with 80% and has Trump's endorsement.

Marshall started with more money in the bank. On FEC filings to 15 July, Hamilton's campaign had raised $4.2 million in 2025-26 to Marshall's $4.0 million, but Marshall held $5.4 million in cash to Hamilton's $1.7 million. Outside groups had spent $3.6 million to help Hamilton in the general election and $1.4 million to help Marshall by 28 September.

The outside money is now arriving. Cook Political Report moved the race to Toss Up on 6 October, and Cook's Jessica Taylor tied the move to Republican groups pulling ad reservations from North Carolina and redirecting them to Kansas. The Daily Caller reported on 12 October that the Senate Leadership Fund planned to spend $14 million for Marshall, and that Senate Majority PAC, on the Democratic side, had launched a $5 million television campaign, including an ad on Marshall's vote against releasing Justice Department files on Jeffrey Epstein. The New York Times reported that Marshall, as a physician, sued more than 700 patients over medical debt, according to the Daily Caller's summary.

The race matters beyond Kansas. It is the deciding seat in 9% of our Senate simulations, level with the Ohio special and behind only Iowa's 10%. A Hamilton win would most likely come on a night when Democrats are already near 51 seats, which is why it so often turns out to be the seat that settles the chamber.

Polling Forecast reads every poll in ten countries, corrects for how pollsters have missed before, and turns them into seats. Our forecasts, the polls and our methods are free to explore.

Our projection and every poll →

Elsewhere on Polling Forecast

Figures as of . Published by Polling Forecast.