New York's 21st district
Called: Anthony Constantino (Republican) wins
Called by us, on the count on 7 November 2026. Unofficial until the state certifies. Our forecast before the count gave Anthony Constantino 83%; it is kept below for the record. Every result and call →
Constantino leads Gendebien by 5.5 points in our forecast
Open seat: Elise M. Stefanik (R) is retiring. Anthony Constantino leads by 5.5 points in our forecast and wins 83% of our simulations. The polls say Constantino by 1.4 points, but polls alone have missed before, so we blend them with the district's lean. Rating: Likely R.
The band runs from 25% to 75% of the vote: the dot is our forecast, the shaded part holds 80% of our simulations, the tick marks 50%. Others: about 1.1%.
How we got here
From the district's 2024 vote for president to our forecast, one step at a time.
What moves the average today
The polls that count most in our average of this race, and their share of its weight.
-
SurveyUSA10%
Counted: after the pollster's usual lean and the national trend since the poll. Every other poll together: 11%.
Our projection R+5.5; 80% of simulations between R+12.7 and D+1.7.
| Share of the vote | Gendebien | Constantino | Others |
|---|---|---|---|
| Our forecast | 46.7% | 52.2% | 1.1% |
| 80% range | 43–50 | 49–56 | |
| The polls | 48.4% | 49.7% | 2.0% |
The polls, as published with undecided voters left out, have R+1.3. Allowing for each pollster's usual lean, the national trend since each poll and how far polls have missed before: R+1.4. Blended with the fundamentals (R+10.3, 46% of the weight): R+5.5. Third parties tend to get less than they poll; we expect a little over half their polled share.
What if the polls are off?
Anthony Constantino leads by 5.5 points in our projection. If the polls are off by more than 5.5 points in the Democrat's favor, Blake Gendebien wins instead.
Our projection: Anthony Constantino by 5.5 (R+5.5).
If the polls miss like a past election
- 2024 R+7.7
- 2022 R+6.5
- 2020 R+12.4
- 2018 R+5.4
- 2016 R+9.3
- 2014 R+8.8
- 2012 R+3.0
- 2010 R+3.8
- 2008 R+6.5
- 2006 R+4.7
- 2004 R+5.8
- 2002 R+9.0
Each past election's average miss in the final Senate and governor polls, applied to this race. None of them changes the winner. The same rule moves every race at once on who wins Congress if the vote moves.
Our forecast over time
Our projection with the range holding 80% of simulations. A month ago: 6% for the Democrat (Likely R); now 17% (Likely R). The shaded part is reconstructed from the polls published by then.
- 19 Aug reconstructedLeans R→Likely R1 new poll in our average (J.L. Partners); poll average D+3.6 to R+4.3; national House vote D+5.8 to D+5.6.
- 10 Aug reconstructedLikely R→Leans R1 new poll in our average (SurveyUSA); poll average R+4.3 to D+3.6.
- 18 Jun reconstructedLeans R→Likely Rnational House vote D+5.5 to D+3.8.
The polls over time
Each dot is one poll's margin on the decided vote as published (click for the poll); the line is a smoothed average (each day weighs the polls around it, and bigger polls more), with its 80% band; at the newest end it can only look back. Our average on the left adjusts each poll for its pollster's past lean; this chart does not.
Embed this race a small card for your own page
How we get there
| Presidential lean | R+19.5 against the nation (2024: R+20.8; 2020: R+15.6) |
|---|---|
| National House vote | D+7.5 (our reading of the generic ballot) |
| Incumbency | No incumbent running |
| Fundamentals alone | R+10.3 ± 7.6 |
| Poll average | R+1.4 ± 7.0 from 8 polls |
| Weight on the polls | 54% |
| Our projection | R+5.5 ± 5.2 |
Fundamentals: 1.1 + 0.98 × lean + national House margin + 1.4 for an incumbent, fitted on 1146 contested districts in 2022 and 2024 and 2026 (typical miss 6.0 points). The two are combined in inverse proportion to their measured errors. Method
The candidates
Blake Gendebien (D)- Anthony Constantino (R)
The member now
Elise M. Stefanik (Republican), since 2015
2026: Incumbent retiring
Who lives here
| Total population (ACS estimate) | 770,419 |
|---|---|
| White alone, not Hispanic or Latino | 88.6% (New York 52.8%) |
| Black or African American alone, not Hispanic | 2.1% (New York 13.4%) |
| Hispanic or Latino (any race) | 3.8% (New York 19.8%) |
| Asian alone, not Hispanic | 1.0% (New York 9.0%) |
| Bachelor's degree or higher, age 25+ | 26.2% (New York 40.2%) |
| Median household income: published B19013 for unchanged districts, bracket estimate for new ones | 70,983 |
| Population living in 2020 Census urban blocks | 37.9% (New York 87.5%) |
US Census Bureau: American Community Survey 2020-2024 and the 2020 Census, on the 2026 lines.
Money
| Candidate | Raised | Spent | Cash | Outside for | against |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Blake Gendebien (D) |
$5.5m | $3.1m | $2.6m | $61k | $40k |
| Anthony Constantino (R) | $9.5m | $8.7m | $3.0m | $0 | $88k |
All 7 candidates who filed for this seat in 2025-26 (primaries included) have spent $16.4m. Outside groups have spent $351k ($244k of it in the primaries). In the general election, $66k has helped the Democrat and $40k the Republican (spending for a candidate, or against their opponent). The money race everywhere
Raised, spent and cash on hand: the candidate's own campaign committees over the two years 2025-26, to the end of the latest report (the newest here runs to 30 June 2026). Outside: independent expenditures reported to the FEC by party committees, super PACs and other groups, including the 24- and 48-hour reports filed close to an election; amended filings replace the original. Figures are as filed.
Data: FEC bulk data, 2026 cycle (candidate summaries) (as of 28 September 2026); FEC independent expenditures (as of 28 September 2026). Grade A: official data from the body that holds it. All sources
The polls in our average
- Tue 13 Oct 2026
(D sponsor) · 613 LV · 13 Oct
Anthony ConstantinoRepublican46
Blake GendebienDemocratic44Anthony Constantino (R) 46 · Blake Gendebien (D) 44Constantino +2- Tue 6 Oct 2026
(D sponsor) · 496 LV · 6 Oct
Blake GendebienDemocratic46
Anthony ConstantinoRepublican42Others 5
Blake Gendebien (D) 46 · Anthony Constantino (R) 42 · Other (OTH) 5Gendebien +4- Sun 4 Oct 2026
(D sponsor) · 500 LV · 4 Oct
Anthony ConstantinoRepublican48
Blake GendebienDemocratic45Anthony Constantino (R) 48 · Blake Gendebien (D) 45Constantino +3- Thu 10 Sep 2026
(D sponsor) · 557 RV · 10 Sep
Anthony ConstantinoRepublican48
Blake GendebienDemocratic43Anthony Constantino (R) 48 · Blake Gendebien (D) 43Constantino +5- Wed 2 Sep 2026
(D sponsor) · 500 LV · 2 Sep
Anthony ConstantinoRepublican47
Blake GendebienDemocratic44Anthony Constantino (R) 47 · Blake Gendebien (D) 44Constantino +3- Mon 17 Aug 2026
500 LV · 17 Aug
Anthony ConstantinoRepublican50
Blake GendebienDemocratic40Anthony Constantino (R) 50 · Blake Gendebien (D) 40Constantino +10- Sat 8 Aug 2026
612 LV · 8 Aug
Blake GendebienDemocratic43
Anthony ConstantinoRepublican39Others 5
Blake Gendebien (D) 43 · Anthony Constantino (R) 39 · Other (OTH) 5Gendebien +4- Sun 31 May 2026
(D sponsor) · 500 LV · 31 May
Anthony ConstantinoRepublican45
Blake GendebienDemocratic44Anthony Constantino (R) 45 · Blake Gendebien (D) 44Constantino +1
Margins on the decided vote. Adjusted: less the pollster's house effect at past final polls and, for a poll paid for by a campaign or party or from a pollster that mainly works for one, less the 2.5 points such polls have leaned to their side. ↻ Moved with the national trend: each poll is moved by how far the national generic ballot has moved since its fieldwork (our trend line through every generic-ballot poll, trackers included, now D+11.5); the "National trend" tag on each card shows its move. Weight: recency (30-day scale), sample, the pollster's record, halved for partisan polls, and a pollster's several polls sharing one pollster's weight.
Other polls of this race
- Thu 10 Sep 2026
- Generic Republican vs. generic DemocratPublic Policy PollingGeneric Republican vs. generic DemocratRepublican +13
(D sponsor) · 557 RV · 10 Sep
Generic RepublicanRepublican53
Generic DemocratDemocratic40Generic Republican (R) 53 · Generic Democrat (D) 40Republican +13 - Thu 16 Apr 2026
(R sponsor) · 300 LV · 16 Apr
Robert SmullenRepublican43
Anthony ConstantinoRepublican33Robert Smullen (R) 43 · Anthony Constantino (R) 33Smullen +10- Sat 28 Feb 2026
(R sponsor) · 500 LV · 28 Feb
Anthony ConstantinoRepublican43
Robert SmullenRepublican16Anthony Constantino (R) 43 · Robert Smullen (R) 16Constantino +27- Sat 31 Jan 2026
(R sponsor) · LV · 31 Jan
Anthony ConstantinoRepublican40
Robert SmullenRepublican26Anthony Constantino (R) 40 · Robert Smullen (R) 26Constantino +14
Primaries, hypothetical matchups and earlier candidates.
Past results
| Year | Winner | Runner-up | Margin |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Elise M. Stefanik (R) 62.0 | Paula Collins (D) 38.0 | R+24.0 |
| 2022 | Stefanik, Elise M. (R) 59.2 | Castelli, Matt (D) 40.8 | R+18.3 |
| 2020 | Stefanik, Elise M. (R) 58.8 | Cobb, Tedra L. (D) 41.2 | R+17.7 |
| 2018 | Stefanik, Elise M. (R) 56.1 | Cobb, Tedra L. (D) 42.4 | R+13.7 |
| 2016 | Stefanik, Elise M. (R) 65.3 | Derrick, Mike (D) 30.2 | R+35.1 |
| 2014 | Stefanik, Elise M. (R) 55.1 | Woolf, Aaron G. (D) 33.8 | R+21.3 |
| 2012 | Owens, William L. (D) 50.2 | Doheny, Matthew A. (R) 48.2 | D+2.0 |
| 2010 | Paul D. (D) 59.3 | Theodore J., Jr. (R) 40.7 | D+18.6 |
| 2008 | Tonko, Paul D. (D) 62.1 | Buhrmaster, James R. (R) 35.0 | D+27.1 |
| 2006 | McNulty, Michael R. (D) 78.2 | Redlich, Warren (R) 21.8 | D+56.4 |
| 2004 | McNulty, Michael R. (D) 70.8 | Redlich, Warren (R) 29.2 | D+41.6 |
| 2002 | McNulty, Michael R. (D) 75.1 | Rosenstein, Charles B. (R) 24.9 | D+50.2 |
| 2000 | Michael R. McNulty (D) 74.4 | Thomas G. Pillsworth (R) 25.6 | D+48.8 |
The district with this number on the lines of each year (lines change after every census and in several states since 2022). ‡ decided in a runoff. Sources: FEC and the Clerk of the House (House), MIT Election Data and Science Lab (Senate), J. Cha (governors).
Photo credits
1 official portrait from the Biographical Directory of the United States Congress (US government work, public domain): Elise M. Stefanik.
- Blake Gendebien: Photo: Blake Gendebien for Congress
Figures as of . Published by Polling Forecast.



