Who stands with whom: the coalition line-up assumption
Abstract. Italian seats depend on the line-up of coalitions, which the parties declare only weeks before the vote. The forecast states its assumption and shows three: the centre-left 'campo largo' with the M5S (the default, as in the regional elections since 2024), the same with Futuro Nazionale in the centre-right, and the 2022 line-up. With the same votes they give very different Camere, by more than any polling error in the record. We explain the choice and what a coalition means in the model.
Summary
Italian seats depend on who stands with whom as much as on the votes. A third of the Camera is elected in single-seat collegi, where each coalition's candidate gets the votes of all its lists, and the proportional seats go first to coalitions and then to their lists. Polls ask about lists. The coalitions are declared only when the parties file their symbols and lists, about six weeks before polling day, and they can change until then. So the forecast needs an assumption about the line-up, and this paper sets out the one we make, the two we show beside it, and how much they change the result.
Our default is the "campo largo": the PD, the M5S, AVS, +Europa and Italia Viva together, as in the regional elections the centre-left has fought since 2024, against the centre-right of FdI, the Lega, FI and Noi Moderati, with Azione and Futuro Nazionale standing alone. The second line-up puts Futuro Nazionale in the centre-right. The third repeats 2022, when the M5S stood alone and Azione and Italia Viva stood together. With the same votes, the three give very different Camere; the gap between them is larger than any polling error in the record.
What has changed since this paper was written
Updated 9 November 2026. The rest of the paper is as first published, except where a sentence below says it was corrected.
The new electoral law is in force (8 October). The Chamber gave the new law its final approval on 8 October 2026, by 227 votes to 164, and the Italian forecast has used it everywhere since. As the forecast applies it to national shares:
Seats are shared in proportion to the vote, by Hare quota and largest remainder, among coalitions on 10% or more and lone lists on 3% or more. Inside a coalition, lists on 3% or more, plus the best list below 3%, share its seats; every list's votes count towards the coalition's total.
The bonus. The coalition or list that comes first with at least 42% of the valid votes gets 70 extra deputies and 35 extra senators, up to caps of 220 deputies and 113 senators.
The Senate is worked out the same way on national shares (the law allocates its seats by region). Seats abroad, Valle d'Aosta and Trentino-Alto Adige are shared in proportion to the national vote, an approximation.
The collegi no longer elect anyone. The maps and collegio pages show who leads each former collegio.
Where this paper describes the Rosatellum, it describes the law under which the 2022 Parliament was elected: it remains the basis of the check against 2022 and of the by-elections in this Parliament. /it/new-law shows the seats under both laws side by side.
- Only elections from 2000 shape the forecast (28 September). Earlier elections stay in the long view and on the history pages but no longer feed any test, correction or error size. In Italy the tests were already on elections since 2001, so nothing changed.
Why the line-up cannot be read from the polls
The Rosatellum rewards coalitions in two ways (From votes to seats: the Rosatellum).
In the collegi, which elect 147 of the 400 deputies, a coalition's candidate gets the votes of all its lists and the most votes wins. Two lists standing apart split their vote in every collegio; together, they add it. A coalition that leads nationally by a few points wins most collegi: in 2022 the centre-right won 121 of 147 with 43.8% of the vote, against a centre-left of 26.1% and an M5S of 15.4% standing apart.
In the proportional count, a coalition with 10% qualifies as a whole, and its lists between 1% and 3% add their votes to it. A small list is worth more to a coalition than on its own.
Neither effect can be read from a poll of list shares. The line-up is decided by the parties, in negotiations that often run to the filing deadline. In 2022 Azione signed an alliance with the PD in early August and left it within a week, to stand with Italia Viva; the M5S, the PD's partner in government until that summer, stood alone. A forecast that assumed the line-up of the previous election would have been wrong in 2022, and could be again.
Three line-ups
| Line-up | Centre-right | Centre-left | Standing alone |
|---|---|---|---|
| Campo largo (default) | FdI, Lega, FI, Noi Moderati | PD, M5S, AVS, +Europa, Italia Viva | Azione, Futuro Nazionale |
| Campo largo; Futuro Nazionale with the centre-right | FdI, Lega, FI, Noi Moderati, Futuro Nazionale | PD, M5S, AVS, +Europa, Italia Viva | Azione |
| The 2022 line-up | FdI, Lega, FI, Noi Moderati | PD, AVS, +Europa | M5S; Azione with Italia Viva; Futuro Nazionale |
Table: The line-ups the site shows. In every line-up the SVP stands alone in its own collegi, and the seats abroad are held at their 2022 result.
Why the campo largo is the default. Since 2024 the centre-left has fought regional elections with the PD, the M5S, AVS, +Europa and Italia Viva in one coalition. Of the line-ups one could assume today, this is the one the parties' own recent practice points to. Azione and Futuro Nazionale, Roberto Vannacci's party, are assumed to stand alone. A site setting chooses the default, and it can be changed when the parties decide.
Why Futuro Nazionale with the centre-right. Futuro Nazionale's deputies in the Camera were mostly elected for the Lega, and it sits on the right. Whether it joins the centre-right coalition is the most uncertain single decision in the next line-up, and, as the table below shows, among the most consequential.
Why 2022. It is the line-up of the last election and the baseline against which the other two can be read: the M5S alone, the centre-left without it, Azione and Italia Viva together.
How much the line-up changes the seats
With today's votes, under each line-up:
| Line-up | Centre-right | Centre-left | Others |
|---|---|---|---|
| Centre-left 'campo largo' with the M5S (our projection) | 143 | 224 | 33 |
| Campo largo; Futuro Nazionale with the centre-right | 224 | 165 | 11 |
| The 2022 line-up | 223 | 96 | 81 |
Three things follow.
The M5S decides the centre-left's size. With the M5S inside, the centre-left adds its vote in every collegio, and a coalition of the PD, the M5S and AVS competes with the centre-right almost everywhere. Without it, as in 2022, the centre-left and the M5S split the vote and the centre-right wins most collegi on a minority of the national vote.
Futuro Nazionale can decide the majority. Standing alone, Futuro Nazionale wins proportional seats only. Inside the centre-right it adds several points in every collegio, which is enough to swing many close ones. The difference between the first two rows is the difference Futuro Nazionale's choice makes with the same votes.
Small lists matter more inside a coalition. +Europa, Italia Viva and Noi Moderati poll below 3%. Standing alone they would win nothing. Inside a coalition they add their votes to its candidates, and, between 1% and 3%, to its proportional total, and they may be given collegi to fight by their partners.
What a coalition is in the model
A coalition in the model is a pre-election alliance: a set of lists supporting the same candidate in every collegio, whose votes count together in the proportional count. The forecast reports each coalition's seats and the chance that the largest one reaches 201. It does not model alliances formed after the vote. A government can rest on a coalition that did not stand together, or on a coalition plus lists that stood alone; the M5S governed with the Lega in 2018 and with the PD in 2019 after standing alone. A "no majority" result in the forecast means no pre-election coalition reached 201, not that no government can be formed.
Three details of the model follow from the line-up.
Collegi by list. The law elects a coalition's candidate, and which list each candidate belongs to is agreed between the parties. The forecast shares each coalition's collegi among its lists by largest remainders on their national shares, including lists under 3%. That is our approximation; the real split is negotiated.
The seat abroad that moves. The eight seats abroad are held at their 2022 result. The M5S's one seat abroad follows the M5S into whatever coalition it joins.
Thresholds follow the line-up. Under the law a coalition needs 10% and a list inside it 3%, while a list alone needs 3%; a list in a coalition that fails 10% qualifies on its own with 3%. The seat engine applies these rules to whatever line-up it is given, so moving a list between coalitions can change whether it wins any proportional seats at all.
The line-up in the rest of the forecast
The simulation (Simulating Italian polling error: where the chances come from), the replays (If we're wrong: replaying past Italian polling misses on today's polls) and the polling-day forecast (From today to polling day in Italy) all run under the default line-up. The chances they report are chances given the line-up, not chances over line-ups: we do not put a probability on the parties' decisions. The home page and the method page show all three line-ups beside each other, and the what-if and prediction tools use the default.
Once the coalitions are declared, the default can be set to the declared line-up.
Limitations
The default is an assumption. It follows the parties' recent practice, and it could be wrong. Every page states it.
Three line-ups are not all line-ups. Azione could join either side; a list could split; a new list could form. Each would need its own row.
No probability over line-ups. The forecast's chances hold the line-up fixed. A reader who thinks another line-up is likely should read that row.
Candidates. The collegio candidates, and so their lists, are chosen when the line-up is. A coalition's list split, and any local strength of a candidate, is unknown until then.
References
DPR 30 marzo 1957, n. 361 (Testo unico per l'elezione della Camera dei deputati), as amended by legge 3 novembre 2017, n. 165.
How to cite
Polling Forecast (2026). Who stands with whom: the coalition line-up assumption. Retrieved 21 November 2026 from https://www.pollingforecast.com/research/italy-coalitions. Live figures change as new polls arrive; the date above is when the text was last revised.



